The Great Heresies

Adquiera una suscripción para descargar libros aquí >>

Solamente la libertad que se somete a la verdad conduce a la persona humana a su verdadero bien. El bien de la persona consiste en estar en la verdad y en realizar la verdad.

— San Juan Pablo II

Hilaire Belloc

INTRODUCTION: HERESY

What is a heresy, and what is the historical importance of such a thing?

Like most modern words, «Heresy» is used both vaguely and diversely. It is used vaguely because the modern mind is as averse to precision in ideas as it is enamored of precision in measurement. It is used diversely because, according to the man who uses it, it may represent any one of fifty things.

Today, with most people (of those who use the English language), the word «Heresy» connotes bygone and forgotten quarrels, an old prejudice against rational examination. Heresy is therefore thought to be of no contemporary interest. Interest in it is dead, because it deals with matter no one now takes seriously. It is understood that a man may interest himself in a heresy from archaeological curiosity, but if he affirm that it has been of great effect on history and still is, today, of living contemporary moment, he will be hardly understood.

Yet the subject of heresy in general is of the highest importance to the individual and to society, and heresy in its particular meaning (which is that of heresy in Christian doctrine) is of special interest for anyone who would understand Europe: the character of Europe and the story of Europe. For the whole of that story, since the appearance of the Christian religion, has been the story of struggle and change, mainly preceded by, often, if not always, caused by, and certainly accompanying, diversities of religious doctrine. In other words, «the Christian heresy» is a special subject of the very first importance to the comprehension of European history, because, in company with Christian orthodoxy, it is the constant accompaniment and agent of European life.

We must begin by a definition, although definition involves a mental effort and therefore repels.

Heresy is the dislocation of some complete and self-supporting scheme by the introduction of a novel denial of some essential part therein.

We mean by «a complete and self-supporting scheme» any system of affirmation in physics or mathematics or philosophy or what-not, the various parts of which are coherent and sustain each other.